When We Call It Magic
There are moments with horses that can take your breath away.
A horse who quietly walks over and rests beside someone who has spent a lifetime believing they were too much. A herd that shifts when a client softens into their body. A horse who chooses connection over walking away. Moments that leave us speechless, wiping away tears because we can’t quite explain what just happened.
People often call those moments magic.
I understand why. But I’ve come to believe that calling them magic actually diminishes what really happened.
The Conversation That Changed Everything
This concept gave way to deep discussions during one of our Natural Lifemanship EAS Residencies this summer. One of our participants had a difficult session with her horse. Things didn’t unfold the way she had hoped. She left the arena looking discouraged. “That sucked,” she sighed as she sat down. I think she even uttered the words, “I sucked.”
As we processed together, she contrasted that session with all the “magical” experiences she had previously shared with this horse.
I paused and gently challenged her. “What if those earlier moments weren’t magic?”
She looked puzzled.
“What if they were every bit as real as this difficult moment?”
She was quiet, but I could see something major shifting.
Evidence, Not Magic
Because if the beautiful experiences are dismissed as magic, as something mysterious or unexplainable, then they become almost accidental. They don’t belong to us and our experience with the horse. We can’t trust them. We can’t learn from them. And when things get hard, all we’re left believing is the painful story we tell ourselves.
“I suck.”
But what if those earlier moments weren’t magic at all?
What if they were evidence? Evidence of genuine connection, of profound attunement. Evidence that two nervous systems had found one another in safety. Evidence that this horse had responded with honesty.
And evidence that the person had done something, too. Maybe they had softened. Maybe they had listened. Maybe they had become clearer, more present, or more responsive. Maybe, together, the horse and person had created something real—something neither one created alone.
That matters, because now there is something to return to.
Not a magical moment we hope will somehow happen again, but an experience we can get curious about. What was happening in me then? What was happening between us? What did I offer? What did the horse offer? What helped us find each other?
Those moments weren’t less real than the struggle. If anything, they revealed something deeply true. They were evidence that this person and this horse had already found their way into connection once—and perhaps could find their way there again.
We Found a Better Word
Throughout the rest of the residency, our cohort kept returning to this conversation. It began changing the way we talked. Not only about our own experiences, but also about the experiences our clients were having.
We found a different word for these experiences.
Sacred.
There was something about that word that felt different. It was more grounded, more honest.
Because sacred doesn’t suggest something imaginary or supernatural. It points to something deeply real, something that changes us precisely because it actually happened.
What Horses Are Really Responding To
Natural Lifemanship has always taught that horses are not magical creatures. They don’t possess mystical powers. They aren’t reading minds or performing miracles. What they’re doing is, in many ways, even more extraordinary. They are responding through relationship.
They often notice our tension before we do. They recognize incongruence between what we say and what our bodies communicate. They respond to regulation, presence, authenticity, boundaries, and connection.
What feels like magic is actually nervous systems communicating exactly as they were designed to. It’s attachment. It’s attunement. It’s co-regulation. It’s relationship. And relationship has always had the power to transform us.
Sacred Is Not Another Word for Magic
Sacred isn’t simply another word for something mysterious, unexplainable, or beyond our understanding. We aren’t replacing one word for mystery with another.
The science helps us understand the very real processes underneath these moments—the ways nervous systems communicate, attachment takes shape, safety is experienced, and connection changes us. Understanding those processes doesn’t make what happens any less extraordinary. It gives us something we can notice, learn from, and practice rather than something we can only hope happens again.
And science, awe, and wonder are not opposites. We don’t have to choose between understanding something and standing in awe of it. For me, the more I understand about what is actually happening between two beings in relationship, the more wonder there is.
And that’s what makes sacred different from magic. Sacred doesn’t describe what we can’t explain. It speaks to the meaning and significance of something profoundly real.
Two beings finding one another in safety, responding honestly, and creating something together that can change them both—and that is sacred.
Understanding more about how it happens doesn’t diminish its sacredness. If anything, understanding it more deeply has only deepened my reverence for what is taking place.
Thin Moments
Natural Lifemanship co-founder Bettina Shultz-Jobe often speaks about what she calls “thin moments.” Similar to the concept of thin places, these are moments when the space between the ordinary and the sacred feels remarkably close—when something profoundly meaningful emerges in what appears to be an ordinary encounter.
I love that image because it invites us to become fully present—to notice, receive, and honor what is happening.
Sometimes what appears ordinary from the outside—a horse moving closer, a person softening, two beings simply being still together—holds something much more profound. These are moments when we experience something every human nervous system longs for: to be seen without judgment, to be met without pretense, to be known without having to perform.
More Beautiful Than Magic
When we call these experiences magic, we unintentionally take something away from both ourselves and the horse. We take away the truth that we were capable of showing up in relationship. We take away the truth that the horse was offering an authentic response. Not because of mystical powers, but because of a willingness to be in relationship with us.
And perhaps most importantly, we miss what was created between us—the relationship itself.
The horse doesn’t create the transformation. Neither do we. The relationship does. We participate in creating it together. And relationships are real. Perhaps that’s why they are so powerful.
So yes, there are moments that still leave me speechless. Moments that bring tears to my eyes. Moments that feel almost impossible to describe. These moments truly are sacred. Because sacred reminds us that something profoundly real just happened.
Something the horse participated in. Something we participated in. Something we can learn from, remember, and return to.
And knowing it’s real makes it even more transformative.
Your Invitation to Step Into the Work
If this reflection resonates with you, the Fundamentals of Natural Lifemanship offers a place to explore more deeply what is happening within these moments of connection. We study the science underneath relationship—the neurobiology of trauma and healthy brain development, attachment, and the ways nervous systems communicate—while also practicing the relational skills that help us participate in genuine connection with horses and humans.
Because understanding relationship doesn’t take away the awe and wonder. It gives us more capacity to notice what is happening, learn from it, and return to it when things get hard.
Fundamentals is also the first step toward Natural Lifemanship Certification.
We invite you to step into the work and discover more about what becomes possible when we learn to understand—and participate more intentionally in—relationship.
Recent Comments